This
one came out of nowhere and it may be one of the
more intriguing albums of the year. Buffalo
Nichols is a young guitarist / singer from
Milwaukee, and has just released the sefl-titled
Buffalo Nichols on Fat Possum. Raise your
hand if you've heard of Mr. Nichols before. Like
with me, I suspect there aren't many hands in
the air. According to his
website, Nichols "cut his teeth between a
Baptist church and bars in Milwaukee," before
traveling through West Africa to bring it all
home. This background has helped him to become a
very good songwriting, covering a range of
topics on his debut album.
Nichols is playing an old style of acoustic
blues, not slavishly recreating the vintage
sounds but instead putting his own heart, soul
and life experiences into his music. With only
eight cuts Buffalo Nichols is shorter
than most albums today, but there's a lot of
very fine blues packed into the less than 30
minutes run time.
The
title of "Lost & Lonesome" tells us what Nichols
is trying to convey on the opening cut,
capturing that feeling of loneliness quite well
in his voice. It's a mid-tempo blues with only
his voice and acoustic guitar telling this
story. His voice gets stronger as the song
progresses as he's feeling more and more lost.
"Living Hell" kicks off the second cut with nice
Piedmont-style fingerpicking on the guitar while
Nichols puts a lot of emphasis in lyrics like
"....Do I die and go to heaven or living hell
..." His frustration with society comes out when
he sings "... Police and crooks, they're the
same to me ..." More very strong fingerpicking
guitar on "Sick Bed Blues," with his voice here
being somewhat reminiscent to a young Bob Dylan.
We've all been sick in bed with no one to come
see us, so we can feel the emotions here.
"These Things" brings a violin into the mix on
this pleasant folk/blues tune, and it's very
effective. Nichols sounds like Dylan again,
perhaps even more so than on other cuts, with
urgent vocals on "How To Love." The
fingerpicking slide guitar work is outstanding
here, and later there's a thumping bass beat
(his foot, perhaps) that drives the song.
"Another Man" takes the blues into a darker side
of the soul, with an intro sounding a bit like
that on Muddy Waters' "Baby Please Don't Go."
But it's Nichols' vocals that dominate this one,
with the anger coming out on lyrics like "...
It's hard to write a song, while folks get
murdered every day, I know it ain't so
simple, I know I'm mad as hell, why should we
choose between a noose and dying in the cell
..." This one gets my nomination for blues song
of the year.
Nichols sounds happier on "Back On Top," with
drum and tambourine accompanying the vocals as
he sings about celebrating and living like a
king. His use of the slide is especially
effective here. The pace picks up on the closing
number, "Sorry It Was You," with steady drumming
pushing the beat along while Nichols lays down a
mean slide guitar solo.
Buffalo Nichols is quite the revelation of a
young artist going back to the early blues, but
in a way that will appeal to modern audiences.
I'm expecting this one to get some crossover
airplay as Fat Possum has always been good about
getting its artists in front of diverse
audiences and not just confining them to the
regular blues circuit. Right now, Nichols is on
tour as the opening act for Drive-By Truckers. I
expect even bigger things from Nichols in the
future, but this superb album is a good place to
start. Highly recommended!
--- Bill Mitchell
I
love a good story when I discover a new blues
artist, and Hanna PK certainly has one to
tell. This
young woman was born and raised in Seoul, South
Korea before winding up in Rochester, New York
sometime in the preceding decade. It was there
that she discovered a love for the blues, and
she put her strong vocal and piano talent into
the music. She's now a regular on the Rochester
blues circuit, and cut albums in 2016 and 2018.
For her latest, Blues All Over My Shoes,
Hanna PK hooked on with Booga Music and VizzTone,
which gets her a much, much wider distribution
than before.
Hanna is a very accomplished piano player,
seamlessly able to switch styles from slow blues
to jazz to barrelhouse and to boogie woogie,
accompanying her somewhat husky voice, and she
wrote every song here except for one. Showing
her diversity in styles of music, she heads
straight to New Orleans for the opening cut,
"Mirror Mirror," with harmonica from Kenny Neal
who also produced the session. "Bad Woman" is a
straight Chicago blues shuffle as Hanna sings
about what has been a common blues theme. Yeah,
talking about her being a bad woman. That leads
into the first slow blues, featuring really nice
piano playing from Hanna as she sings about the
"Insomnia Blues."
It's
back to New Orleans on the Memphis Slim cover,
"I'm Lost Without You," but getting funkier on
this excursion, before Hanna launches into a
slow ballad blues, "Love Keeps Walking In." One
of my faves is the up-tempo "It's Alright Baby,"
still sounding like we're in New Orleans but
with heavy winds blowing in from the Gulf. We're
then heading for church on the slow, soulful "No
One Will Ever Know," with Brandon Adams coming
in on organ to complement Hanna's tasteful piano
playing . She sings words of encouragement to
someone "born out of wedlock" as this individual
picks up a guitar and hits the road.
More
gospel-style piano on the pleasant, lilting "Ain't
Gonna Be Looking Back No More," as Hanna
sings about picking herself up and moving on to
better days. Very nice piano solo midway
through, perhaps her best work yet on the 88s.
That leads into what just may be my favorite
song, as Hanna shows she can sing some serious
blues on the slow number that starts with nice
jazzy piano. Now that I've listened to it again,
I'll confirm that this slow blues is the
highlight of the album. I just shouted out a big
"Wow!"
The
jazzy "Bad Habit" almost sounds like something
that Lambert, Hendricks & Ross would have done,
with enough echo in Hanna's vocals that make it
sound like there are two of her at the mic. The
two Hannas sing about the evils and the
addiction of smoking, and her staccato notes on
the piano are very effective. Wrapping up this
exciting new collection of tunes is "Two And
Four," a boogie woogie dance number that has
Hanna pounding away on the keys. It's a great
ending to an absolutely fun album.
Hanna PK is an artist with plenty of growth
ahead of her, so I can't wait to hear what's
next. Blues All Over My Shoes is a good
introduction to the wider blues audience base,
and hopefully the next step is to get this young
woman on tour. If she hits my town, I'll
certainly be there.
--- Bill Mitchell
Patricia
Silverberg is somewhat of a regular on the
Arizona folk scene, and I had the chance to
review an earlier album by her nearly a
decade ago. When she reached out to me recently
to tell me about her latest six-song EP (or
maybe we just call it a shorter album), the
self-released Just the Way You See It, I
encouraged her to send it my way, especially
when she said that she was doing more blues on
this one. What I remember from that earlier disc
was that Ms. Silverberg possessed a deep, dark,
foreboding voice that suited the chosen
material, and that still applies on this album,
perhaps even more so. It's not a voice that will
sooth your soul, but will instead haunt your
inner demons.
Silverberg is accompanied by a rotating group of
solid musicians on each cut, while she sings and
plays a very nice guitar. Five of the six songs
are originals, with the album opener being the
old Leadbelly blues number, "Midnight Special."
Anne James contributes harmonica accompaniment
on this one to contrast with Silverberg's voice,
which sounds even deeper here. "Just the Way You
See It" starts with pleasant guitar picking
before Silverberg's commanding vocals come in to
tell someone not to waste her time because she's
got better things to do. Ms. James' mandolin
playing is a nice touch.
"What Were You Thinking" is a more gentle tune
with Silverberg's voice lightening up quite a
bit, although I still prefer her darker side.
Her voice fits much better into the the
mid-tempo blues, "Working Class Blues," with
David Searle on lead guitar. While "Gift of Pure
Light" isn't as much of a blues, it's a pleasant
tune with nice guitar work and strong emotive
vocals. Closing the album is "Lullaby Moon," and
it's pretty much what the title says about it.
Silverberg's voice handles the heartfelt lyrics
quite well, with the highlight on this number
being Bea Graves' cello accompaniment. Very
nice.
If
you follow the Arizona folk scene, be sure to
watch when Ms. Silverberg is playing somewhere
near you. She'll be glad you came.
--- Bill Mitchell
I’m
writing this review on November 9th, which
happened to be the release date for Layla and
Other Assorted Love Songs in 1970. That
particular album has a special place in my
heart, as it served to expose me to several
things, the guitar prowess of Duane Allman for
starters. It was also some of the first blues
rock that I heard back in the early ’80s, and
it’s still one of my favorite albums from Derek
and the Dominos, and one of my favorite
albums ever.
November 9th in 1970 also happens to be Susan
Tedeschi’s birthday. As most blues fans are
aware, Tedeschi is married to guitarist Derek
Trucks, who was actually named after the “Derek”
in Derek and the Dominos. Their band, the
Tedeschi Trucks Band, has incorporated
several Derek and the Dominos songs into their
live shows over the years. Trucks himself
enjoyed a 15-year stint with the Allman Brothers
Band and has toured with and as part of Eric
Clapton’s band. It really made sense for the
band to pay tribute to Derek and the Dominos in
a big way, and what better way than to perform
the Layla album live in its entirety.
Layla Revisited (Live at Lockn’) (Fantasy
Records) was recorded on August 24, 2019 at the
LOCKN’ Festival in Arrington, Virginia. The band
was joined onstage by Trey Anastasio and Doyle
Bramhall II. Anastasio joins Tedeschi and backup
singer Mike Mattison, with their vocals blending
perfectly. The album is played in sequence,
beginning with “I Looked Away,” which features
all three singers. Their collaborative efforts
leave goosebumps time after time. Tedeschi is
simply one of the finest singers currently
practicing, and she and Mattison have worked
together seamlessly for over a decade now.
Anastasio’s presence makes the performance even
better.
The
performances are by no means note-for-note
recreations, but when they are, as on “Bell
Bottom Blues” or “Why Does Love Got To Be So
Sad,” it’s still dynamite. The alterations,
really more like adjustments made to the songs,
work just fine. For “Keep On Growing” (one that
the band has played before as part of their live
show), there’s an extended jam to open the song.
Hey, there’s four great guitarists here, why
not?
“Anyday,” a staple of the Derek Trucks Band’s
live sets in the early 2000s. also allows for
plenty of guitar work, as does “Key To The
Highway” and “Have You Ever Loved A Woman.” The
band’s read on “Tell The Truth” is pretty
righteous, too, and the title track, known and
loved by so many, is just as powerful and
heart-rending in the TTB’s version as it was on
the original.
The
band opted not to do the original album closer,
“Thorn Tree In The Garden,” on stage, preferring
to close things out with the title track, so
Tedeschi and Trucks recorded a lovely studio
version that wraps the album up perfectly, just
like on the original Layla.
When
you think about it, it’s only appropriate that
one of the finest bands of the current era
should recreate one of the finest albums of the
last half-century. Layla Revisited will
by no means replace the original Layla,
but it serves as a wonderful companion piece,
and it wouldn’t be a bad thing at all if it were
to lead some new listeners to the original.
--- Graham Clarke
Milwaukee-based Blind Fiction is a
blues-rock trio (Tim Wright – lead
guitar/vocals, Eric Madunic – bass/backing
vocals, Nick Lang – drums) that produces a
unique, original musical approach while drawing
from musical influences Eric Clapton, the Allman
Brothers Band, John Mayer, and the Grateful
Dead. Overlook is their second release, a
tasty set of 11 original tracks.
The
disc opens with the upbeat “Better Man,” a
lively rocker with a bit of a country flavor.
“Old News” is a bit smoother, adding a little
funk to the mix, and “Deal With You Later” mixes
in some pop qualities with the harmony vocals,
featuring some standout fretwork from Wright.
“Ignorance Is Bliss” effectively mixes R&B with
blues and rock, and “Mean Old Jack” is a tough
blues rocker punctuated by slide guitar from
Wright.
The
edgy “Ugly Side” is a powerful rock-edged
workout, the upbeat “Better Than New” is a tight
pop rocker, and “Waiting On A Tragedy” is a
strong mid-tempo ballad. Meanwhile, “Breaking Me
Down” is an energetic blues rocker, and “Haunt
You” is a soulful slow burner that works really
well. The album closer, the reflective “You
Never Know,” deftly mixes blues and R&B.
Blind Fiction also gets some noteworthy
contributions from Joe Howard (keyboards), Eric
Schoor (tenor sax), Jamie Breiwick and Andrew
Riehle (trumpets), and Tim Preuss (bass).
Overlook should appeal to any blues fan who
also digs a variety of musical genres, powerful
guitar work, and catchy rhythms.
--- Graham Clarke
Kerry Kearney is a slide guitarist
extraordinaire who’s been honing his craft for
over 40 years. We reviewed his excellent
Smokehouse Serenade release in
late 2019. Tales From the Psychedelta
(Highlander Records) consists of previously
released material from several of Kearney’s
previous albums, making it a “Best of” set of
sorts. The 12 tracks mix contemporary blues rock
with more traditional Delta blues fare, making
for a tremendously well-rounded set capturing
Kearney at his very best. Since some of his
previous releases are out of print, this is a
great opportunity to hear tunes that you’d
otherwise miss.
The
opener, “Five Time Man,” is a pretty intense
blues rocker, followed by “Fatherless Boy,”
which is a more sedate number with a southern
rock flavor as Kearney plays dobro. There’s also
a rollicking “Mississippi River Stomp,”
featuring searing slide guitar that brings to
mind Sonny Landreth, and an up-tempo version of
the old standard “Trouble In Mind” that really
kicks. Sam “Bluzman” Taylor joins Kearney on
vocals for the country blues/gospel “Thank You
Jesus,” and the funky and energetic “Memphis
High” sets the bar pretty high for the second
half of the disc with Kearney’s scorching slide.
Arthur Crudup’s “Mean Old Frisco” is the album’s
second cover, with Kearney’s mid-tempo, country
blues approach very effective. “Voodoo Down The
River” has a nice swampy feel with Kearney and
Tony Campo going back and forth on slide and
organ, respectively, while “Lawdy Mama,” the
last of three covers, positively burns in a
terrific fast-paced read. “Runnin’, Weepin’,
Tremblin’” is as close to a slow burner as
you’re going to get on this collection, with
Kearney getting ample opportunity to ply his
craft on the smoking six-minute track.
The
jaunty “World Train” marries the blues and
bluegrass, with Kearney on dobro along with
guests “Papa Jim” Fleming on mandolin and
Charlie Wolfe on harmonica. The closer,
“Schaefer Time/Duck House,” is a wonderful
wrap-up to the collection, with Kearney doing a
masterful job with this acoustic medley.
Tales From The Psychedelta is the perfect
introduction to the music of Kerry Kearney, one
of the finest slide guitar masters currently
practicing.
--- Graham Clarke
Live from El Paso (811 Gold Records LLC) is
the latest release from Laura Tate, a
fine set recorded at the McKelligon Canyon
Amplitheatre, located in the singer’s home base.
Tate is backed a superb band, which includes
Terry Wilson (bass, vocals), Doug Hamblin
(guitar), Tony Braunagel (drums), Jeff Paris
(piano, vocals), Teresa James (backing vocals),
Joe Sublett (sax), Lee Thornburg (trombone), and
Darrell Leonard (trumpet). The 12-song set mixes
blues, soul, R&B, jazz, and Americana, reprising
several songs from Tate’s previous releases.
The
jazzy mid-tempo “No Place To Hide” opens the set
with nice work from the horns in support of Ms.
Tate’s sultry vocal. “I’ll Find Someone Who
Will,” written by James and Wilson for Coco
Montoya, is a solid rocker that provides a great
showcase for both Tate’s vocals and the horns.
It’s followed by a dynamite read of the Thin
Lizzy(!) hit “The Boys Are Back In Town” ---
definitely not the usual approach to the hard
rock classic, but Tate’s version is most
impressive. The smoky “I Need A Man” is a slow
burn blues, “Hittin’ On Nothin’,” from Allen
Toussaint (credited to Naomi Neville), is a nice
Crescent City-flavored number, and “Can’t Say
No” is a Latin-tinged ballad.
The
pensive “Still Got The Blues” keeps the pace on
the mellow side (nice guitar solo from Hamblin
at the midpoint), and the mid-tempo “Nobody Gets
Hurt” has a smooth country feel. The upbeat
shuffle “What A Way To Go” picks up the pace a
bit, before seguing into “Cowboy Jazz,” a ballad
featuring a cushy horn chart backing Tate’s
superb vocal. “Big Top Hat” is a horn-fueled
Texas rocker, followed by the soulful “If That
Ain’t Love” that closes the set.
Proceeds from the concert went to the El Paso
Community Foundation’s Laura Tate Fund for the
Arts, and there’s no doubt that everyone in
attendance got their money’s worth. If you
missed Tate’s earlier releases, this is a great
opportunity to get a taste of what you missed,
but those albums are definitely worth a listen
as well.
--- Graham Clarke
Gerald McClendon, a.k.a. “The Soul Keeper,”
returns with Let’s Have a Party! (Delta
Roots Records), and his sophomore effort is even
better than his wonderful 2020 release, Can’t
Nobody Stop Me Now. Like its predecessor,
the new release teams McClendon and
songwriter/drummer/producer Twist Turner with a
stellar group of musicians, including guitarists
Rico McFarland, Melvin Taylor, Joe Burba, and
Rusty Zinn, bassist Johnny B. Gayden,
keyboardists Tony Llorens, Sumito Ariyoshi,
Brian James, and Jim Pugh, and the Delta Roots
Horns.
Turner wrote all 12 tracks, and they deftly walk
the line between blues and soul. The opener,
“Keep On Keepin’ On,” is a gospel-flavored
message of inspiration for these tough times,
while “If It Ain’t The Blues” checks all the
boxes as Turner’s song reflects on hard times,
McFarland contributes stinging lead guitar, and
McClendon testifies with gritty fervor.
Meanwhile, the enthusiastic title track is a
good-time tune driven by Gayden’s rumbling bass
and the horn section, notably Skinny Williams’
sax, and McClendon does a fine job on the sweet
old school soul ballad “Pretty Girl.”
McClendon shows his lady the door on the feisty
“Pack Your Bags and Go,” when he finds a pair of
dirty drawers on the floor, and he provides
timely commentary on “Ghetto Child,” a poignant
picture that hits home far too often in today’s
world. “You Got To Be Strong” is another message
of inspiration and determination with a strong
vocal from McClendon and sublime support from
Ariyoshi on piano and John “Boom” Brumbach on
sax. McFarland teams with Burba on guitar for
the slow blues “Throw This Dog a Bone,” and
“Start All Over Again” is a superb bit of
country soul that sounds like a long-lost Muscle
Shoals track.
“I
Just Can’t Help Myself” is another terrific slow
burner with more great fretwork from McFarland
and Burba, with the latter really shining with a
potent solo on the somber “I Just Can’t Take
Anymore” . The mood picks up considerably with
the album closer, “Funky Stuff,” which features
Taylor’s skittering guitar work and Brian James
on keyboards.
For
fans of vintage soul, blues, and R&B, Let’s
Have a Party! is what you’ve been looking
for. Gerald McClendon effortlessly works through
these 12 excellent songs with support from some
of the Windy City’s best musicians, resulting in
one of the best releases of the year to these
ears.
--- Graham Clarke
Corey Ledet’s latest album, Corey Ledet
Zydeco (Nouveau Electric Records), pays
tribute to Ledet’s family and his musical
heritage. His great-grandfather, Gabriel Ledet,
played upright bass with jazz legend Bunk
Johnson, his grandfather, Buchanon Ledet, played
drums with Clifton Chenier and Rockin’ Dopsie
(inventing “double clutchin’” rhythm in the
process), and others played with B.B. King and
Bobby Bland.
Ledet himself has enjoyed a successful career as
a zydeco artist over the past couple of decades,
with Corey Ledet Zydeco his 14th album
overall. Like its predecessors, it incorporates
blues, gospel, rock n’ roll into the zydeco mix
with exciting results.
Ledet began recording in early 2020, but was
forced to cut the sessions off due to pandemic
concerns. He ended up recording some of it by
himself, playing drums and washboards on several
tracks, but he receives fine support on other
tracks from an excellent group. Cecil Green
(Hammond B3), Lee Allen Zeno (bass), Grant
Dermody (harmonica), Julian Primeaux
(guitar/background vocals), and Gerard Delafose
(drums/washboard).
The
opening track, the rollicking “This Is All I
Want,” serves as a mission statement of sorts
for Ledet, as he proclaims that wants to play
his zydeco music and spend time with his family.
“Buchanon Ledet Special” is a hard-charging
tribute to his grandfather, and Delafose gives
it his all behind the drum kit. The lively “Mon
Marche” is actually Fats Domino’s “I’m Walkin’”
sung in Ledet’s native dialect Kouri-Vini. “Pel
Mo (Call Me)” is also in Kouri-Vini, and is more
blues-based, with Dermody contributing on
harmonica. The exuberant “On A Roll” has a bit
of a reggae feel in the rhythm.
The
enthusiastic cover of Big Joe Turner’s “Flip,
Flop, and Fly” is first-rate and bound to get
dancing feet on the floor, and the reassuring
“It’s Gonna Be Alright” is a dandy combination
of zydeco and swamp pop.
Ledet cut the last three tracks by himself, due
to the pandemic. The first is the instrumental
two-step “Nina’s Hot Step,” that demonstrates
his prowess on the accordion. Next is “Mon Make
(I Miss),” a beautiful old school waltz, and the
closer, “Arét Tu Trin (Stop Your Noise),” is a
lot of fun with Ledet playing accordion, drums,
and washboard.
Corey Ledet Zydeco is a fine tribute to the
music that inspired Corey Ledet over the years.
While it is a tribute, it’s not derivative at
all, paying respects to the predecessors of the
genre but also showing that music still has a
lot of life and energy left. LOADS of life and
energy. If you’ve never listened to zydeco, this
is a perfect place to get on board.
--- Graham Clarke
For
Polly O’Keary and the Rhythm Method, 2021
was a pivotal year. All of the band members
turned 50, hence the title of their new release,
50. The band (O’Keary – bass/vocals, Dave
Miller – guitar/vocals, Tommy Cook –
drums/vocals) spent all of 2020 working on this
release, taking advantage of the downtime
incurred by the pandemic to work on what turns
out to be their best release to date, crafting
11 fine original tunes written by the band that
mix blues, rock, R&B, funk, and Americana.
The
opener is a strong, optimistic blues rocker,
“Brand New Day,” which features the band’s
long-time friend Lady A (the REAL one) on guest
vocals with O’Keary. The feisty “Too Much Like I
Care” is a hard-driving shuffle with some nice
fretwork from Miller, and he mixes in some
Santana-esque fills on the Latin-flavored
anti-drug number “Can’t Catch Me.”
The
slow burner “Smiling” is one of three tracks
featuring Miller’s vocals, and he does a fine
job on this track as well as on the Americana
number, “People On The Corner,” and the
country-flavored rocker, “American Highways,”
which closes the disc.
O’Keary takes the mic again for the stomping
rock n’ roller “You Better Think,” tears into
the moody blues “Strange Way Of Showing Love,”
ably handles the urban blues of “ABC’s,” and
pulls out all the stops on the shimmering blues
rock ballad “I’m Not Guilty” (the best overall
track on the disc, to these ears). Meanwhile,
her exuberant performance on the funky pop-soul
number “Love In Waiting” is a genuine pleasure.
Polly O’Keary and the Rhythm Method is a band
that deserves to be heard with two excellent
vocalists in the mix, some of the best
songwriting around days, and their versatility
in a number of styles (always wrapped up in the
blues). 50 should appeal to a variety of
music fans, and hopefully, it will lead to even
better things for this fine band.
--- Graham Clarke
Soulful singer and songwriter Brigitte Purdy
recently issued the single “Stylin’.” This
joyous, upbeat track mixes blues, soul, and R&B
and is bound to put a hop in your step. Ms.
Purdy has a voice that’s a comfortable fit in a
number of genres. Thankfully, she’s devoted to
blues and soul.
The
musical support is perfect and it’s impossible
to sit still while you’re listening, trust me.
We’re hoping that “Stylin’” is just the start of
more great recordings to come from Ms. Purdy.
--- Graham Clarke
Any
previously unheard recording by John Coltrane
is cause for celebration, so the 1965 live
recording A Love Supreme: Live In Seattle
(Impulse!) is a welcome release for Coltrane
fans.
Good
stereo balance of McCoy Tyner’s piano, bass and
drums. Horns off-microphones seemingly in
between the channels, but audible enough to take
in. (Had to have been a lengthy reel of tape not
recorded at high speed? How else could a
consumer recording engineer in 1965 capture the
entire hour and 15 seamlessly? Pure audio, not a
dropout or splice detectable). Performance quite
inspired, ‘Trane must’ve felt better about this
night than the only other known live recording
of this work at Antibes (sometimes credited to
Paris, on which has been documented that he felt
he “played badly”).
Vibe
in the Penthouse room feels good, more people
there than the LP set of other stuff (which was
a Thursday and this was a Saturday). Idle
musicians got carried away with percussion toys
when they weren’t playing. Trane throws quotes
of “Cosmos” and “Evolution” (things he’d gone
way out with the previous Thursday) into places
of this Love Supreme. The two-bass
sections are nice in a couple places through the
work.
Joe
Brazil’s or Carlos Ward’s alto solo in one
movement is compatible, Pharaoh Sanders’ tenor
solos might work for his hardcore fans, but I
was disappointed when Coltrane gave the entire
third movement sax solo space to Sanders. Just
doesn’t do it for me. The audience thinks the
work is over after three movements, a rousing
lengthy round of crowd applause approval,
perhaps a standing ovation. A voice, I hope not
one of the newest musicians just joining the
group for this gig, asks “Is that it?” (Go to
your room, listen to the studio album
repeatedly! A hot seller by the time of the
Penthouse gig). Jimmy Garrison does his usual
exemplary single note and chordal bass solo
before the final movement, even if on recordings
after all these years he can get quite lengthy.
When
the fourth movement, “Psalm,” hits, one can feel
the favorable spiritual state Coltrane must have
been in at that moment. For a while it sounds
like he may be “reciting” the prayer on his horn
which was printed inside the original album
foldout. An attempt to follow those words during
this Penthouse version proves this was not the
case, he was simply improvising close to the
meaning behind the prayer. His sax tone is purer
than the hi-register places he’d gone during
this same movement back in July ’65 at Antibes,
and the length of the sax solo is actually a
little shorter than the original studio record.
One
more bias of mine against Pharaoh Sanders: If
he’d been familiar with the LP recording of
Love Supreme by the time of this gig (again
it had been out maybe nine months), he would
have joined Trane for the two-sax effect on the
“Amen” final note of Psalm’s prayer. Where was
Sanders when we needed him? Instead of Elvin
Jones getting the last word on a drum, which was
usually the case on many studio and live
recordings, one of the bassists lingers, wishing
to keep expressing how he felt. The room sounds
after everything is over are interesting.
Voices, apparently of those other than the
original Quartet, loosely discuss a post-mortem
of the work just experienced.
--- Tom Coulson
|